Carol P. Coady serves as Interim President/CEO of Florida Lawyers Mutual Insurance Company, effective June 16, 2026, having previously served as an integral part of Company operations for more than 20 years.
In her prior role as Operations Manager at Florida Lawyers Mutual, Ms. Coady oversaw a wide scope of responsibilities in service to the Company’s members, including managing administration, HR, corporate governance, and regulatory compliance. As the organization’s senior-most operations leader for more than twenty years, she facilitated numerous functions in the areas of underwriting, claims, accounting, marketing, information technology, data security, facilities management, and community engagement. As a longstanding leader at the only lawyers’ professional liability insurance company created by The Florida Bar, she worked closely with leadership across the Florida legal community, including voluntary bar associations, community resource providers, and The Florida Bar. She was also instrumental in completing the purchase of Florida Lawyers Mutual’s current headquarters in Oviedo, FL.
Prior to joining Florida Lawyers Mutual in 2003, Ms. Coady developed an extensive background in law, working as a paralegal and legal assistant for multiple firms in Central Florida, as well as in Washington, D.C. Her experience includes supporting practices across real estate, business law, insurance defense, and products liability litigation. These experiences allowed Ms. Coady to develop meaningful insight into the real-world experience of Florida lawyers, informing her commitment to serving those lawyers with excellence as a part of Florida Lawyers Mutual leadership.
Back to Florida Lawyers Mutual Leadership
Back to Florida Lawyers Mutual Team Directory
